Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Episode 3: The Hypocrisy of Boring

QUICKFIRE CHALLENGE

Quickfire Winner:
  • Hugh Acheson - Team Waffles = 2 points
Quickfire Runner Up:
  • Mary Sue Milliken - Team Waffles = 1 point
Quickfire Losers:
  • George Mendes - Team Fornian = -1 point
  • Suvir Saran - Team Milvio = -1 point
Quickfire Totals:
  1. Team Waffles = 3 points
  2. Team Milvio = -1 point
  3. Team Fornian = -1 points
ELIMINATION CHALLENGE

Elimination Challenge Winner: 
  • Naomi Pomeroy - Team Fornian = 6 points
Elimination Challenge Runner Up:
  • Suvir Saran - Team Milvio = 3 points
Elimination Challenge Losers:
  • Mary Sue Milliken - Team Waffles = -1 point
  • John Currence - Team Waffles = -1 point
  • Celina Tio - Team Fornian = -1 point
SAYONARA: John Currence

Elimination Challenge Totals:
  1. Team Fornian = 5 points
  2. Team Milvio = 3 points
  3. Team Waffles = -2 points
Episode Totals:
  1. Team Fornian = 4 points
  2. Team Milvio = 2 points
  3. Team Waffles = 1 point
STANDINGS
  1. Team Waffles = 11 points
  2. Team Milvio = 10 points
  3. Team Fornian = 7 points
What had looked like a pretty commanding lead for Team Waffles has shrunk to the slimmest of margins. Such is the up and down world of the Top Chef Fantasy League! On top one week, and kicked in the stomach the next. Making matters worse for Waffles, for the third consecutive week, a member of the team was eliminated. Had it not been for the miraculous resurrection of Hugh Acheson, Waffles would be down to Mary Sue Milliken for the rest of the season.

The winner this week was Team Fornian, though they did not pick up a ton of points thanks to a couple of bad performances by George Mendes and Celina Tio. Let it be known that there is no team in the league that can lose points in a Quickfire Challenge like Team Fornian. Three weeks of competition, and five points already lost to the Quickfire.

Of course, the good news for Team Fornian is that, even though they're in last place, they are the only team with all four of its chefs remaining. This could provide a large advantage in the coming weeks, or it could just mean that the next few weeks could be painful. We must wait and see.

As for why I titled this week's post "The Hypocrisy of Boring," that had to do with the Elimination Challenge. On one hand, you had John Currence being sent home for his risotto. A dish that the judges said tasted fine, but just wasn't daring enough. It was too boring.

Yet, the winner this week was Naomi Pomeroy, who did nothing but create a cream of broccoli soup with some pretty little garnish on top and lemon oil. That dish is daring? I realize the patrons voted on this, but it just felt wrong to me.

Though the biggest debacle was that it wasn't Celina Tio sent home. Yes, I know she's on my team, but she should have been gone. The judges said they liked both John and Mary Sue's dishes, but they expected more. Meanwhile, not a single one of the judges liked Celina's pudding.

So why the hell is she staying? So what if the other two chefs weren't daring enough, at least they cooked good food! Isn't that what you want from your meal? For it to taste good.

So believe me when I say I feel your pain, Team Waffles. I feel you were screwed over this week just like I'm sure you do.

No comments:

Post a Comment